Elliptical machine: how to choose one for home
We research products from makers' specs and health sources; we do not run hands-on tests. Links to Amazon may earn us a commission at no cost to you. How this works.
- Compact magnetic elliptical. Best for: Smaller rooms and lighter users. See options on Amazon
- Heavy-duty 16 inch stride elliptical. Best for: Users who want a longer stride and a higher user limit. See options on Amazon
- Foldable elliptical. Best for: Homes that need floor space back after workouts. See options on Amazon
What an elliptical does
An elliptical is a standing cardio machine. Your feet stay on the pedals through the whole stride, which is different from running where each foot lands with every step.
A study of 30 adults measured weightbearing on an elliptical trainer and found average values for the whole foot of 70% to 81% of body weight, even at higher resistance and incline. The authors concluded that elliptical training significantly reduces weightbearing on the foot.
Like any cardio, it counts toward activity goals. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans say adults need at least 150 to 300 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity each week.
Compact vs heavy-duty: two examples
| Spec | Sunny compact magnetic | Sunny heavy-duty |
|---|---|---|
| Stride length | 11 in | 16 in |
| Max user weight | 220 lb | 330 lb |
| Pedal step height | 6.5 to 12.8 in | 6.9 to 15 in |
| Resistance levels | 8, magnetic | 15, magnetic |
| Flywheel | Not listed | 15.4 lb |
| Size | 40.7 x 26.4 x 59.8 in | 61.4 x 27.2 x 66.5 in |
| Machine weight | 62.8 lb | 113.8 lb |
All figures are from Sunny Health & Fitness's published specifications. Both use a belt drive and list a 3 year structural frame warranty with 180 days on other parts.
Specs that matter
- Stride length. This is how far the pedals travel front to back. Short strides fit compact machines; longer strides give a fuller step. Compare it across models; Sunny's examples run from 11 to 16 inches.
- Max user weight. Leave room above your own weight. The two Sunny examples list 220 lb and 330 lb.
- Pedal step height. The pedals lift you off the floor. Sunny lists a maximum step height of 12.8 inches on the compact model and 15 inches on the heavy-duty one, so check your ceiling clearance with your own height plus that rise.
- Footprint. Full-size ellipticals are long. The heavy-duty Sunny is 61.4 inches long; the compact one is 40.7 inches.
- Resistance. Magnetic resistance is common. More levels give finer steps.
- Moving the machine. Both Sunny examples have transport wheels, which matters at over 100 lb.
Knees, joints and the research
Ellipticals are often called gentle on joints, but the research is more specific. A small study of 12 healthy men compared stationary bikes and elliptical machines at 50 and 70 revolutions per minute. Elliptical machines produced higher knee joint torque than stationary bikes, and faster pedaling raised peak knee torque on both machines.
The timing of the load also differed. Peak knee torque came earlier in the pedal stroke on the bikes, at 70°-110°, and later on the ellipticals, at 135°-180°. The researchers also noted that constant pedaling on elliptical machines limited the ankle angle and could induce inward rotation. With only 12 participants, all healthy men, the results may not apply to everyone.
The authors concluded that elliptical machines showed higher peak forces and torque, indicating potential challenges to the knee joint. If you have knee problems, an exercise bike or a recumbent bike may be worth comparing, and it is worth asking your doctor or physical therapist which suits you.
Using an elliptical safely
- Hold the stationary handles when stepping on and off.
- Begin at a low speed; the knee study found faster pedaling raised joint load.
- Keep children and pets away from the moving arms and pedals.
- Place the machine on a level floor with clearance on all sides.
- Stay under the maximum user weight.
What to look for when you buy
Compact magnetic elliptical
Best for: Smaller rooms and lighter users
Sunny's compact model lists an 11 inch stride, 8 magnetic levels and a 40.7 inch length.
Watch out: 220 lb user limit and a shorter 11 inch stride.
See options on AmazonHeavy-duty 16 inch stride elliptical
Best for: Users who want a longer stride and a higher user limit
Sunny's heavy-duty model lists a 16 inch stride, 15 levels, a 15.4 lb flywheel and a 330 lb limit.
Watch out: 61.4 inches long and 113.8 lb. Check ceiling clearance with the 15 inch pedal height.
See options on AmazonFoldable elliptical
Best for: Homes that need floor space back after workouts
Foldable ellipticals are widely sold for home use.
Watch out: Check the stride length, user limit and folded size on the maker's spec sheet.
See options on AmazonQuestions people ask
- What does an elliptical do?
- It gives you standing cardio with your feet staying on the pedals, which research shows reduces weightbearing on the foot.
- Is an elliptical easier on the knees than a bike?
- Not necessarily. A small study found higher knee joint torque on ellipticals than on stationary bikes.
- What stride length should I get?
- Compare models. Sunny's examples range from an 11 inch compact stride to a 16 inch heavy-duty stride.
- How much space does an elliptical need?
- Check length and pedal height. Sunny lists 40.7 to 61.4 inch lengths and step heights up to 15 inches.
- How long should I use an elliptical?
- Adults need 150 to 300 minutes of moderate aerobic activity a week, per the Physical Activity Guidelines.
Sources
- Smart Compact Magnetic Elliptical (sunnyhealthfitness.com), Sunny Health & Fitness
- Smart Heavy-Duty Elliptical Training Machine (sunnyhealthfitness.com), Sunny Health & Fitness
- Effects of Stationary Bikes and Elliptical Machines on Knee Joint Kinematics during Exercise (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov), Medicina (PMC10972514)
- Clinical Implications of Changing Parameters on an Elliptical Trainer (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov), Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine (PMC4555606)
- Top 10 Things to Know About the Second Edition of the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans (odphp.health.gov), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (ODPHP)