Home / Recovery, stretching and yoga
Sleep masks for side sleepers: the features that stop light leaks and pressure
We research products from makers' specs and health sources; we do not run hands-on tests. Links to Amazon may earn us a commission at no cost to you. How this works.
- Slim contoured foam mask with a hardware-free strap. Best for: Most side sleepers who want full darkness. See options on Amazon
- Adjustable eye-cup mask with a thin strap. Best for: Side sleepers with wide-set or deep-set eyes who get leaks from fixed shapes. See options on Amazon
- Wide, soft headband-style mask. Best for: Side sleepers who dislike any strap or edge. See options on Amazon
- Sleep mask with molded foam earplugs included. Best for: Side sleepers dealing with both light and noise. See options on Amazon
Why side sleeping is hard on sleep masks
On your side, one half of the mask is pressed into the pillow all night. Three things tend to go wrong:
- Pressure at the temple. A thick edge or a buckle on the strap presses into the side of the head. The Sleep Foundation warns that plastic or metal band adjusters may cause discomfort by pressing into the side of the head.
- Light leaks. The pillow pushes the mask up or sideways, opening a gap by the nose or under the eye on the top side.
- Pressure on the eye. A flat mask squashed against the pillow can press on the lower eyelid.
A good side sleeper mask solves all three: thin and soft at the sides, a strap with no hard parts, and a shape that keeps fabric off the eye even when squeezed.
Why full light blocking is worth chasing
Light at night is not just a nuisance. In a Northwestern University study published in PNAS, sleeping one night with moderate room light (100 lux) instead of dim light (3 lux) raised heart rate during sleep and was followed by higher insulin resistance the next morning. The researchers suggested an eye mask or blackout shades when outdoor light cannot be controlled.
The Sleep Foundation has also reported on research in which adults aged 18 to 35 who blocked light with an eye mask for a week showed better alertness and memory, and in which people wearing a light-blocking mask did better on cognitive tests than people wearing a mask with holes over the eyes. The point for side sleepers: a mask that leaks light on one side gives up part of the benefit. The Sleep Foundation notes that a mask blocking 90 percent of light is far less effective than one blocking 95 to 99 percent.
Mask styles compared for side sleeping
| Style | Side sleeping fit | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Slim contoured foam | Good; cups keep fabric off the eyes and the edge is thin | Can feel warm |
| Adjustable eye-cup mask | Good seal if cups are positioned well | Cups can press if set too far back on the face |
| Flat silk or cotton | Comfortable and thin | Tends to lift and leak light when pressed |
| Wide headband style | Even pressure all round, no hardware | Covers the ears, which can feel warm |
| Weighted | Usually too bulky on the pillow side | Better for back sleepers |
For a closer look at cupped designs, see contoured sleep masks. For a softer, flat option, see silk sleep masks.
Fit tips for side sleepers
- Put the strap above the ears, around the back of the head, not over the ear. Less to press on.
- Tighten just enough to seal. Too loose and the pillow drags it; too tight and it presses on the cheekbones.
- Check the nose bridge. That is where most light gets in. Foam masks that conform to the face help here, as the Sleep Foundation notes.
- Pair it with the right pillow. A pillow that fills the gap between ear and shoulder means less of your head weight pushes on the mask. See our guide to a pillow for side sleepers with neck pain.
- Wash it often. The pillow side picks up oil and moisture. The Sleep Foundation notes most masks are machine or hand washable, but repeated washing wears them down.
What to look for when you buy
Slim contoured foam mask with a hardware-free strap
Best for: Most side sleepers who want full darkness
The Sleep Foundation notes foam masks are designed to conform to the face, and that recessed eye cavities usually suit people who find masks irritating. A strap with no plastic or metal adjusters avoids pressure on the side of the head.
Watch out: Foam can feel warm on hot nights.
See options on AmazonAdjustable eye-cup mask with a thin strap
Best for: Side sleepers with wide-set or deep-set eyes who get leaks from fixed shapes
Manta Sleep describes eye cups that slide along the strap and says its mask suits back, belly and side sleep. Movable cups let you fit the seal to your face.
Watch out: The cups add some thickness on the pillow side; position them so the edge does not dig in.
See options on AmazonWide, soft headband-style mask
Best for: Side sleepers who dislike any strap or edge
A stretchy band spreads pressure evenly around the head with no buckle. It stays put when you turn because it grips a wider area.
Watch out: Covers the ears, which some find warm or muffling.
See options on AmazonSleep mask with molded foam earplugs included
Best for: Side sleepers dealing with both light and noise
The Sleep Foundation notes many masks are designed to be worn with earplugs, and some come with a pair.
Watch out: Earplugs can be uncomfortable on the pillow side; soft foam types press less.
See options on AmazonQuestions people ask
- Can you wear a sleep mask if you sleep on your side?
- Yes. Choose one with a thin edge and no plastic or metal strap adjusters, which the Sleep Foundation warns can press into the side of the head.
- Why does my sleep mask let light in when I sleep on my side?
- The pillow pushes the mask up or sideways. A contoured or headband style that grips more of the face usually seals better.
- Are contoured masks good for side sleepers?
- Usually, yes. The cups keep fabric off the eyes even when the pillow presses on one side.
- Is a weighted sleep mask good for side sleepers?
- Usually not. The added bulk sits between your head and the pillow; weighted styles tend to suit back sleepers.
- How do I stop my sleep mask from coming off at night?
- Wear the strap above the ears, tighten it just enough to seal, and consider a wide band style that grips more of the head.
Sources
- Best Sleep Masks (www.sleepfoundation.org/best-sleep-masks), Sleep Foundation
- Close the blinds during sleep to protect your health (news.northwestern.edu), Northwestern University
- New Sleep Mask Benefit Unlocked: Improved Brain Function (www.sleepfoundation.org/sleep-news/sleep-masks-improve-brain-function), Sleep Foundation
- Manta Sleep Mask (mantasleep.com), Manta Sleep