Home / Relaxation and mental wellness
Adult coloring books: what they can do for stress, and how to pick one
We research products from makers' specs and health sources; we do not run hands-on tests. Links to Amazon may earn us a commission at no cost to you. How this works.
- Mandala adult coloring book, single-sided pages. Best for: People who enjoy repetitive patterns and longer sessions. See options on Amazon
- Bold and easy large-print coloring book. Best for: People who prefer larger shapes and bold outlines. See options on Amazon
- Color by number book for adults. Best for: People who find choosing colors stressful. See options on Amazon
- Stress-relief coloring book with perforated pages. Best for: People who want to frame or share finished pages. See options on Amazon
- Colored pencil set for adult coloring. Best for: People starting with a book that recommends pencils. See options on Amazon
Do adult coloring books help with stress?
Mayo Clinic Health System describes coloring as a way to focus on the present and take a break from stressful thoughts. It encourages coloring without judging the result, and says some people do not find the activity relaxing. These are suggestions for a hobby, rather than proof that a particular book treats a mental health condition.
Controlled studies are small. In a 2018 paper in Frontiers in Psychology, Mantzios and Giannou compared university students during 10-minute coloring sessions:
- The first experiment analyzed 84 students. Its results section reports that anxiety scores fell in both the mandala coloring and free-drawing groups, with no significant advantage for mandalas.
- The second experiment involved 72 students. Coloring with mindfulness guidance from a meditation teacher reduced anxiety more than unguided coloring, but the overall analysis did not show an increase in mindfulness.
These short student experiments do not establish lasting benefits, a treatment effect, or which commercially sold book is best. They also do not establish that an ordinary breathing recording reproduces the guided intervention. Choose a design as a matter of preference, rather than expecting a mandala or a stress-relief label to produce a special health effect.
How to choose an adult coloring book
- Level of detail. Inspect an uncolored page preview. Look at the smallest spaces, not just the cover. If you dislike precise work, consider bold outlines and larger shapes instead of intricate patterns.
- Single-sided pages. This leaves the reverse of each design blank. It does not make the paper bleedproof; ink can still reach a sheet underneath. Check the book and pen instructions before using markers.
- Paper compatibility. Look for a stated paper weight and the publisher's recommended media. Thickness alone is not a guarantee of marker compatibility. Do not assume a book intended for pencils is also suitable for paint or wet ink.
- Removal and binding. Check for perforations if you want to display finished pages. For example, Dover describes its Creative Haven books as printed on one side with perforated pages. That describes this publisher's series, not every adult coloring book.
- Theme. Nature, animals, mandalas, cities and quotes offer different subjects. Choose pictures you want to spend time with; the study did not rank those themes.
If working near the spine bothers you, inspect the binding and inside margin before buying. A spiral format may appeal, but confirm that the specific book opens comfortably and that its rings will not sit where you rest your hand. Check the printed design size against the book dimensions rather than assuming a large cover means large artwork.
Types of adult coloring books
| Type | Good for | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Mandala and pattern books | People who enjoy repetitive patterns | Inspect the smallest spaces in the preview |
| Bold and easy or large print | People who prefer larger shapes and less intricate work | May not suit people who want intricate artwork |
| Color by number | People who dislike choosing colors | Less creative choice; small numbers can be hard to read |
| Scenes and landscapes | People who like a finished picture | Check whether the amount of detail appeals to you |
How to color for relaxation
Mayo Clinic Health System suggests coloring without pressure to finish or get everything right. Try these habits:
- Focus on the colors and the movement of your pencil. When your mind wanders, gently return to the activity.
- Pay attention to steady, comfortable breathing without making the session a performance.
- Color at your own pace. Leave a picture unfinished and come back to it if you like.
You do not need spoken guidance to enjoy a book. Some participants in the research disliked being guided, so quiet coloring is also a reasonable preference. If coloring feels frustrating, stop or choose another hobby. A jigsaw puzzle offers a different screen-free activity, and a stress ball is another option for keeping your hands occupied.
Before starting a full design, check how your chosen pencil or pen behaves on a spare sample area when the publisher allows it. For markers, follow any directions about removing a page or using a protective backing. Keep the surface beneath the book protected; a blank reverse side is not a protective barrier by itself. Choose a surface and lighting that let you see the details without holding an uncomfortable position.
What to look for when you buy
Mandala adult coloring book, single-sided pages
Best for: People who enjoy repetitive patterns and longer sessions
A mandala book suits someone who likes repeated shapes. Single-sided printing leaves the reverse blank; check the publisher's media guidance before adding pens or markers.
Watch out: The student experiment found no anxiety advantage for mandalas over free drawing. Inspect the detail and paper rather than buying for a special calming effect.
See options on AmazonBold and easy large-print coloring book
Best for: People who prefer larger shapes and bold outlines
This format is worth considering if small, intricate spaces do not appeal to you. Judge the actual page preview before choosing.
Watch out: Large print is a listing description, not a guarantee of accessible artwork. Check the smallest spaces and lines yourself.
See options on AmazonColor by number book for adults
Best for: People who find choosing colors stressful
A printed color key gives you a plan if you prefer not to decide which colors go where. Check whether the required colors and supplies are included or sold separately.
Watch out: Check that the printed numbers are large enough to read comfortably.
See options on AmazonStress-relief coloring book with perforated pages
Best for: People who want to frame or share finished pages
Perforations are intended to help remove pages for display. Confirm this feature on the specific edition and check that the artwork has a useful margin for your frame.
Watch out: Stress relief on the cover is marketing, not proof of a treatment effect. Page removal does not guarantee tear-free results.
See options on AmazonColored pencil set for adult coloring
Best for: People starting with a book that recommends pencils
Match a pencil set to the publisher's recommended materials and to the colors you want. Check whether a sharpener is included and how you will store the set.
Watch out: A large set is not essential. Confirm paper compatibility rather than assuming all pencils feel or behave the same on every book.
See options on AmazonQuestions people ask
- Are adult coloring books good for anxiety?
- They may help some people enjoy a relaxing break. Mayo Clinic Health System suggests them as a hobby, while the cited research involves short student sessions and does not establish treatment for an anxiety disorder.
- What are the best adult coloring books for stress relief?
- Choose by theme, detail level and paper compatibility. The cited experiment found no anxiety advantage for unguided mandalas over free drawing, and did not compare commercial books.
- What should I color with?
- Follow the book publisher's recommended media. Pencils are an option when the book recommends them; markers require checking ink and paper compatibility. Single-sided pages alone do not prevent bleed-through.
- Are color by number books good for adults?
- They can suit adults who prefer a suggested color plan. Preview the numbers and color key, and check whether you already have the colors it requires.
- How long should I color to relax?
- The cited experiments used 10-minute sessions, but that is not a proven dose for relaxation. Mayo Clinic Health System says you can color at your own pace without finishing a picture in one sitting.
Sources
- Coloring is good for your health (mayoclinichealthsystem.org), Mayo Clinic Health System
- When Did Coloring Books Become Mindful? Exploring the Effectiveness of a Novel Method of Mindfulness-Guided Instructions for Coloring Books to Increase Mindfulness and Decrease Anxiety (frontiersin.org), Frontiers in Psychology
- Creative Haven Adult Coloring Books (store.doverpublications.com), Dover Publications